Best Neighborhood Restaurant: Bexley

The Top Steakhouse

27.4% of 9,672 votes

Walking into The Top is kind of like time-traveling to a classic ‘50s supper club. Dim lights. Wood paneling. Leather seats. Strong drinks. Steaks as big as your face. A piano softly playing Chet Baker in the back. The whole shebang. Considering that the owners chose not to remodel since they opened their doors in 1955, this is as authentic as it gets. We suggest sitting at the piano for one of the coolest experiences the Columbus dining scene has to offer.

2891 E Main St. |

2 Rusty Bucket Restaurant & Tavern 22%

3 Giuseppe’s Ritrovo 14.4%