by Megan Leigh Barnard

Best Neighborhood Bar: Worthington

Old Bag Of Nails

20.3% of 3,755 votes

Who needs a new bag of nails when you got the Old Bag Of Nails? It’s not just that this, the very first location of the Old Bag of Nails pub, has been around forever, but it’s old enough that it would be beyond the legal drinking age. Nestled in a cobblestoney corner on High in historic Old Worthington, it’s just a short stumble away from the town square, and surrounded by well-preserved age-old structures, all adding to the old world pub vibe. Plenty of pints have been poured, and plenty of fish and chips have been eaten within these cozy walls.

663 High St. |

2 Pies and Pints 18.7%

3 The Pub Out Back 10.8%