by Julian Foglietti

Neighborhood Restaurant (Polaris/Westerville)

Carfagna’s Kitchen – 19% of 8,090 votes

We knew it was good idea when a popular local butcher shop decided to open up a restaurant a few years back, and so did their patrons. Not only have they been able to transition the business model of family tradition into a sit-down setting, but they also won our reader’s poll for best spot in Polaris/Westerville once again. Our aprons are off to ya.

2025 Polaris Parkway |

2  Polaris Grill 14.3%

3  Molly Woo’s 13.9%

Carfagna’s Also Won:

Best Meat Market / Butcher – 32.9% of 4,087 votes

2  Weiland’s 2.2%

3  Giant Eagle Market District 10.3%


Carfagna’s Kitchen – 20.2% of 8,058 votes

2   Molly Woo’s 16.5%

3   Polaris Grill 15.2%



Travis Hoewischer

I've been working in journalism in central Ohio for more than a decade, and have been lucky enough to be a part of (614) Magazine since the very first issue. Proud to live in a city that still cares – and still reads.