By Jon McAllister

Neighborhood Bar (Gahanna/Easton)

Old Bag of Nails – 16% of 3,732 votes

The nearly ubiquitous local chain has been keeping customers happy with their no-frills pub menu for years now, pleasing the happy hour crowd, the weekday rec leagues, and the parents trying to catch a night away from the kitchen. It’s also not a bad way to catch a fresh seafood dish in land-locked central Ohio.

Multiple Locations |

2  The Goat Gahanna 14.3%

3  Gatsby’s  14%


The Goat – 31.4% of 3,655 votes

5940 New Albany Rd. |

2  Rusty Bucket 22.7%

Average Joe’s 16.8%