Neighborhood Bar Hilliard

Lucky’s Grille and Sports Pub – 23.7% of 3,500 votes

Clear your mid-week evenings for Lucky’s Wednesday night trivia, where you’re enticed to flex your brain in order win prizes and a “coveted trophy.” Good food, cheap beer, and the coveted cognitive domination of your peers? That’s about all you’ll need.

5387 Roberts Rd. |

2  Rooster’s – 23.4%

3  Otie’s – 17.1%


Lucky’s Grille – 32.4% of 3,633 votes

“Decades of excellence; a community of friends.” Lucky’s has backed up that mantra for 20 years in Hilliard, taking neighborhood bragging rights for the second year in a row. They keep it simple—think pitchers and pub fare—but aren’t afraid to add new features for their regular crowd, like Big Bad Music Trivia on Thursdays.
5387 Roberts Rd. |

2  Rooster’s 27.8%        3  Nasty’s Sports Bar and Grill 20.6%