by Collins Laatsch

Ice Cream

Graeter’s Ice Cream – 34.6% of 10,713 votes

Jeni’s prevailed in this race last year, and though we expected a close battle, we didn’t expect anything like this. We can’t fault our voters for selecting Graeter’s this time around. Despite its origination in Cincinnati, Graeter’s has slowly crept its way into the hearts of the 614. Just writing this makes us wanna grab a scoop.

Various locations |

2  Jeni’s  34.5%

3  Whit’s  8.9%


Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams – 36.7% of 10,688 votes

Various locations  |

  Graeter’s Ice Cream 34.3%
3   Whit’s 7.5%