by Eric Wagner

Hidden Gem

Katalina’s Café – 21.6% of 8,569 votes

What are the hearts of Columbus worth? Over a million pancake balls, apparently. Katalina’s comes back as Best Hidden Gem for another consecutive year, proving that the nooks and crannies of the capital city leave much to be discovered by newcomers and natives alike.

1105 Pennsylvania Ave. |

2  Basi Italia 17.4%

3  The Top Steakhouse 17.2%


Katalina’s Café – 18.4% of 8,413 votes

2   Basi Italia 17.4%
3   The Top Steakhouse 16.6%