by Brian Kaiser


Arch City Tavern – 31.0% of 13,272 votes

How about a shake(up) to go with those fries? One of the biggest surprises in this year’s poll is the emergence of Arch City Tavern. It’s not that Five Guys has fallen out of favor; I mean, how could anyone resist that bottomless bag of fries? But sometimes, a pesky upstart will deal a knockout blow to the odds-on favorite.

862 N. High St. |

2  Five Guys 18.2%

3  Rusty Bucket 5.7%


Five Guys Burgers and Fries – 23.8% of 10,343 votes

Multiple locations  |

2  Tatoheads 14.0%
3  Rusty Bucket 7.6%