614 Magazine - Columbus, Ohio

Become a fan of (614) Magazine on Facebook

JUN2009

Lederhosen optional

Power lunch in German Village

By Steve Croyle

Bookmark and Share

German Village derives its name from the war of 1812, when Hessian forces, led by Hans Gruber, occupied the south end of the city. To prevent them from advancing any further, the Supreme Allied Commander of Ohio forces, Buck Reinhardt, commissioned the construction of the 70/71 split. For the next 220 years the German military struggled to figure out how to get off of the entrance ramp. Most of them ended up in Wheeling, West Virginia. This clever endeavor also prevented the northern migration of hicks, hillbillies and rednecks from places like Kentucky, West Virginia, and Grove City.

What was left behind is a classic Old-World urban neighborhood, complete with narrow brick streets and quirky bars, delis and restaurants - and all nestled among the historic homes. The German heritage of the area is tastefully low-key, and most businesses opt not to be decked out in Bavarian-themed festoonery. Thank God.

Club 185 has been part of that vibe for over 50 years now. In spite of a name that has a trendy post-modern ring to it, it's not a bourgeois hot spot. What you have is straightforward neighborhood bar that offers cheap drinks, good food and a cool-but-unpretentious setting, with exposed brick and a pressed tin ceiling.

There's no patio, they don't have 60 different beers on tap, and the staff isn't going to annoy you with its tragically hip, just-expressing-my-individuality-by-doing-what-all-the-other-emo-kids-do attitude. It's also not one of those grumpy old man bars that smells like mothballs and features glasses smudged with Super Poly Grip denture cement - a happy medium for those just looking for a damn bar.

The crowd one recent Tuesday night was large enough to keep the two servers too busy to talk to me. (I could have played the 'I'm a writer' card, but it accumulates d-bag points, and I really don't need any more of those while I wait for an ill-advised 70s moustache to grow in.) I was able, while I held my credit card hostage, to ask if it was a typical weeknight crowd.

"It's normal for a night like this," the bartender, reaching in vain for the card, informed me, "but when the weather's bad, it's 10 times busier."

On a Tuesday?

"Yep."

Damn.

Most of the patrons were locals, and since the servers seemed to know them, I assumed they were regulars as well. It was the jeans-and-t-shirt set. I had just missed the post-work posse of lawyers, lawmakers, and lobbyists who also put in appearances during the lunch rush.

Club 185 is the kind of bar you wish you had in your neighborhood. Most visitors avail themselves of the church parking lot across the street without any trouble. That's probably not an accepted practice during services, but otherwise it seems fine. If you opt to park elsewhere, just mind the signs, but, cheerily, if you do get towed, the impound lot is not too far away.

Club 185

185 East Livingston Ave.
(614) 228-3904

Originally Published: June 1, 2009

Bookmark and Share
Back to the top

Comments

  1. I wish the actual history of German Villlage was this interesting.

    Brad | 2009-06-04 - 06:44:44 PM (CDT)
  2. I think this is a weak article and misrepresentation my favorite German Village bar : (

    michelle | 2009-06-05 - 04:49:44 PM (CDT)
  3. I thought it was pretty funny. I had to read that opening paragraph twice to realize it was a joke.

    Seymour | 2009-06-06 - 11:50:15 PM (CDT)
  4. I had to check this place out over the weekend. It’s a pretty cool bar. Nothing special, but it’s really nice. Like the guy said, you wish it was in your neighborhood. I live off of Polaris and its all chains.

    danny | 2009-06-08 - 10:54:47 AM (CDT)
  5. I hit 185 from time to time. I think the article is on point. What’s your take Michelle? Am I missing something?

    Don Price | 2009-06-08 - 02:33:18 PM (CDT)
  6. Club 185 is overrated and this article is a waste of space. Sure, it’s cool if you live within walking distance but there are a dozen bars within 2 miles of 185 that are as good or better. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a nice place, just not worth the ink.

    Andy | 2009-06-09 - 06:13:49 PM (CDT)
  7. I don’t think this should be a debate about whether there are better bars and it’s not fair to slam Club 185 for being mediocre or overrated. I didn’t laud it with undue praise and Club 185 certainly doesn’t pimp itself as the premier pub in town. Club 185 is a nice place. I really liked it and if it was convenient to where I live and/or work I’d probably be there a lot, even though the beer selection was a little weak for my tastes (but I’m a real beer geek). They have good food, good drinks and good prices all nestled in an old building with lots of personality. The patrons were pleasant, the staff was attentive and I enjoyed my evening. Is it my favorite bar? No. I honestly don’t know if I have a favorite, but Club 185 would certainly be on my short list. If you make a special trip from Westerville or Worthington you might be a little nonplussed, but if you’re thirsty and happen to be in the area, give Club 185 a shot. I doubt you’ll be disappointed.

    Steve Croyle | 2009-06-10 - 05:00:11 PM (CDT)
  8. I love this bar and I thought the article was great.

    tony | 2009-06-25 - 11:55:27 AM (CDT)
  9. Lame area, lame bar, uppity Dbags throughout

    Will | 2009-10-13 - 02:41:59 AM (CDT)
Your Thoughts,
Name: (required)
To protect everyone from terrible spam, please enter the following code: (required)
captcha
* Offensive comments will be deleted!

ADVERTISEMENT