The Worthington Inn – 15.8% of 8,473 votes
The Inn has been a Worthington staple for decades—an iconic, Victorian-style pub that has been serving up culinary classics for over 30 years. The building was constructed in 1831, meaning The Worthington Inn isn’t just a top-notch grub hub, but a prodigious member of Worthington’s rich history.
649 High St. | worthingtoninn.com
2 Natalie’s Coal Fired Pizza 15.5%
3 Old Bag of Nails 15.4%