Featured Venue

  • Home
  • /
  • (614)
  • /
  • Best Neighborhood Restaurant (Polaris / Westerville)

Best Neighborhood Restaurant (Polaris / Westerville)

Carfagna’s Kitchen

20.2% of 8,058 votes

A family-owned Italian restaurant serving all the classics you love made with traditional recipes is our readers’ favorite in the northern suburbs. Carfagna’s brings its old Columbus roots to a newer part of town.

2025 Polaris Parkway  |  carfagnasrestaurant.com

2   Molly Woo’s 16.5%

3   Polaris Grill 15.2%

Carfagna’s Also Won:

Best Meat Market / Butcher 

28.3% of 4,616 votes

2   The Andersons 15.6%

3   Whole Foods Market 10.3%



Travis Hoewischer

I've been working in journalism in central Ohio for more than a decade, and have been lucky enough to be a part of (614) Magazine since the very first issue. Proud to live in a city that still cares – and still reads.