25.1% of 7,966 votes
The Barn’s classy-meets-rustic vibe makes it a local favorite, and the top pick for New Albany restaurants. Where better to get the best beef than out in the country? Having 70 different kinds of bourbon available doesn’t hurt either.
1370 E Johnstown Rd. | thebarncolumbus.com
2 Rusty Bucket 20.4%
3 Hudson 29 16.6%